The background case in “Cases in..” serves as the basis for the Final Case Solution but is not taken into consideration in the grading of the Final Case; only the solution will be graded. Students must solve the case and upload onto this Moodle using given submission point.
wordcount 4000+-
24 hours only
TITLE
Final Case in _____________
This case was written by _________________________ under the direction of Prof. _________________, EU Business School (Barcelona).
DATE________________,
Outline Case Introduction 3 Problem opportunities / challenge identification / dilemma 3 Main facts and events of the core study 3 Research and analysis of the situation 3 Formulation of solutions / answers 3 Discussion and selection of solutions / answers 4 Referencing 4
Case Introduction
Write here
Problem opportunities / challenge identification / dilemma
Write here
Main facts and events of the core study
Write here
Research and analysis of the situation
Write here
Formulation of solutions / answers
Write here
Discussion and selection of solutions / answers
Write here
Referencing
Write here
2 | Page
image1.png
,
This case was written by ______from class of Cases in Finance leaded by Professor _____.
Tourism Company Finance Hilton Hotels
Monday, April 26, 2021
Abstract
Tourism started way before all the technology before airplanes and cars. It started with basic needs. They are looking for food and water, for instance. Nomads, even though tourism is not their purpose, traveling and not having a fixed home can look like a type of tourism, nowadays people instead travel and do tourism than being home.
Getting to meet new cultures and beliefs, look at new sights are part of a touristic journey and together, comes to the money invested on it.
Tourism is one of the world’s major economic sectors. It is the third-largest export category, after fuels and chemicals, and in 2019 accounted for 7% of global trade and is also highly affected by Covid 19.
This case aims to provide an insight into how tourism enterprises are and will be affected by covid 19 in the economy. It will illustrate the benefits of tourism and what to expect after being highly affected by the pandemic.
Key words: Tourism, economy and enterprises
TOURISM COMPANY FINANCE
10
Introduction
According to United Nations World Tourism Organization (UNWTO), 1.4 billion people traveled to international locations in 2018. The research results conducted 68 years before estimates only 25 million people traveled to international locations.
Due to Covid 19, this number dropped. Companies all around the world are suffering from a lack of tourism. For this Case Study we will focus on Hilton Hotels one of the hotel chains that has branches globally. The financial report focuses on Income Statements and shows a summary of the cash flow and the difference in the financial records because of Covid 19.
COVID 19 has had adverse effects on the economy of most countries, especially in the tourism sector. The economies of scale show a change of the supply and demand curve where the supply is more than the demand. Several countries depend on tourism to improve the economy and contribute to the country's GDP. Tourism is the third-largest income generating in most countries, and the pandemic has affected the industry globally (Bakar et al, 2020).
Problem Situation
The pandemic caused an immediate halt to the economic activity and functions in the industry. The tourism industry is among the industries that have the most adverse effects because of the pandemic, with the significant effect being the loss of jobs due to redundancy. Tourism sectors such as hotels, airlines because of the reduced number of clients. The loss of clientele is contributed by the lockdown and cessation of movements, hence making people stay indoors and making their food at home instead of eating out in hotels and restaurants. The industry depends on clients who bring revenue; hence, revenue loss means no income to the employees. Most of the tourism facilities are private companies that do not have the government's support; hence, this means that the government cannot cushion the businesses as they wait to recover. Most of
the managers did not have other plans or alternatives on sustaining their financial obligations apart from an immediate reaction to stop employees from carrying out their roles because of the possibility of lack of income. The loss of livelihood by the people working and depending on tourism has increased at an all-time high in the last year due to the adverse effects from the COVID 19.
The travel ban placed by various countries means that there is a limitation of tourists from different countries. The pandemic hit worse in the European countries, which affected the economy in Europe and had a ripple effect in developing countries in Africa that highly depend on foreign tourists to boost their economy (Bakar et al, 2020).
There is an effect in finance because companies have resulted to increasing on their expenses to comply with the regulations set by the government in the countries. The employee's safety is vital in sustaining their health. as a measure to protect the staff members and clients, the management needed to install and implement hygiene points in various sections of the business such as hotels and restaurants. Despite the costs incurred installing the safety measures, the businesses in the tourism industry and not in a position to increase the client's prices because of the low demand from clients (Bakar et al, 2020). Therefore, the financial reports show an increase in the loss is contributed by cost increase and reduced prices as a way of attracting clients. An additional cost incurred, such as an increase in furniture to cater for clients and allowing for social distance, means that most of the tourists' sector was affected by the installation and implementation. For example, a restaurant with a sitting capacity of 30 people meant reducing the number of sitting capacity due to the issue of social distance (Bakar et al, 2020).
Some of the tourist sector investments, such as hotels and restaurants, are owned by foreign investors. Due to the adverse effects caused by the pandemic, most of the investors resulted in disposing of their investments as a risk mitigation strategy and avoiding losses in the future. Some investors experienced the challenges of raising capital to resume the business or reinvest when the curve began to flatten because of the increase in financial institutions' restrictions (Bakar et al, 2020).
The increase in the rate of infection affects the performance of work for employees. A reported case of a single person results in the closure of a facility to stop the spread of the virus. If there is an instance an employee contract the virus, the facility may have an option to close for a duration that costs the business revenue during the downtime. Employees spend money on their treatment in the case where health insurance does not apply. The cost of treatment is high, and this reduces the purchasing power for an individual. In the case of a potential client, tourism is considered a luxury item; hence when a person does not have the purchasing power, they automatically do away with the luxury items (Bakar et al, 2020).
The economic projection of the drop in revenues is likely to continue because of the lack of employment from many sectors due to the pandemic's adverse effects. In some cases, some affected industries may choose to forgo taking a holiday in the next two to three years as a way of trying to recover their finances (Williams et al, 2021).
The productivity in some countries in Europe and America depends on seasons. In summer, most people take breaks and are more productive in other seasons, including winter. The COVID 19 reported cases in several European countries reached the peak from March to August, during which Summer falls in between these months. The tourism sector was highly affected in 2020 during these months because it is the norm to take a break and visit tourist
destinations in their home countries or foreign countries. There was a limitation of movement for most people due to lockdowns and cessation to stop the virus's spread. There was a low probability of recovery in the tourist peak seasons. Most potential customers resolved to keep their money in case of an emergency or resulting from different waves or strains of the disease (Williams et al, 2021).
|
Hilton Worldwide Holdings Financial Statements 2018-2020 |
||||
|
Income Statement |
||||
|
Year |
2020 |
2019 |
2018 |
|
|
Revenue |
4,307.00 |
9,452.00 |
8,906.00 |
|
|
Cost of Goods Sold |
620.00 |
1,254.00 |
1,332.00 |
|
|
Gross Profit |
3,687.00 |
8,198.00 |
7,574.00 |
|
|
R & D Expenses |
||||
|
SG & A Expenses |
311.00 |
441.00 |
443.00 |
|
|
Other operating income of Expenses |
(3,422.00) |
5,754.00 |
5,374.00 |
|
|
Operating Expenses |
4,725.00 |
7,795.00 |
7,474.00 |
|
|
Operating Income |
(418.00) |
1,657.00 |
1,432.00 |
|
|
Total Non-Operating Income / Expense |
(506.00) |
(413.00) |
(354.00) |
|
|
Pre – Tax Income |
(924.00) |
(1,244.00) |
1,078.00 |
|
|
Income Taxes |
(204.00) |
358.00 |
309.00 |
|
|
Income After Taxes |
(720.00) |
886.00 |
769.00 |
|
|
Other Income |
– |
– |
– |
|
|
Income from continuous operations |
(720.00) |
886.00 |
769.00 |
|
|
Income from discounted operations |
– |
– |
– |
|
|
Net Income |
(715.00) |
881.00 |
764.00 |
|
|
EBITDA |
(41.00) |
2,048.00 |
1,800.00 |
|
|
EBIT |
(418.00) |
1,657.00 |
1,432.00 |
|
|
Basic Shares Outstanding |
277.00 |
287.00 |
302.00 |
|
Shares Outstanding |
279.00 |
290.00 |
305.00 |
|
|
Basic EPS |
(2.58) |
3.07 |
2.53 |
|
|
EPS – Earnings Per Share |
(2.56) |
3.04 |
2.50 |
|
|
(2.56) |
3.04 |
2.50 |
Cash Flow Statement
|
Hilton Worldwide Holdings Cash Flow Statements 2018-2020 |
|||
|
Cash Flow Statement |
|||
|
Year |
2020 |
2019 |
2018 |
|
Net Income / Loss |
(720.00) |
886.00 |
769.00 |
|
Total Depriciation And Amortization – Cash Flow |
377.00 |
391.00 |
368.00 |
|
Other Non-Cash Items |
97.00 |
(35.00) |
21.00 |
|
Total Non-Cash Items |
474.00 |
356.00 |
389.00 |
|
Change in Accounts Receivable |
488.00 |
(105.00) |
(161.00) |
|
Change in Inventories |
– |
– |
– |
|
Change in Accounts Payable |
– |
– |
– |
|
Change in Assets / Liabilities |
880.00 |
148.00 |
110.00 |
|
Total Change in Assets / Liabilities |
954.00 |
142.00 |
97.00 |
|
Cash Flow from Operating Activities |
708.00 |
1,384.00 |
1,255.00 |
|
Net Change in Property, Plant and Equipment |
(46.00) |
39.00 |
(72.00) |
|
Net Change in Intangible Assets |
(46.00) |
(124.00) |
(87.00) |
|
Net Acquisitions / Divestitures |
– |
– |
– |
|
Net Change in Short-term Investments |
– |
– |
– |
|
Net Change in Long-term Investments |
– |
– |
– |
|
Total Net Change in Investments |
– |
– |
– |
|
Other Investing Activities |
(15.00) |
(38.00) |
28.00 |
|
Cash Flow from Investing Activities |
(107.00) |
(123.00) |
(131.00) |
|
Net Long-term Debt |
2,469.00 |
653.00 |
671.00 |
|
Net Current Debt |
– |
– |
– |
|
Total Debt Insurance / Retirement Net |
2,469.00 |
653.00 |
671.00 |
|
Net Common Equity |
(296.00) |
(1,538.00) |
(1,721.00) |
|
Net Total Equity |
(296.00) |
(1,538.00) |
(1,721.00) |
|
Total Common & Preffered Stock |
(42.00) |
(172.00) |
(181.00) |
|
Financial Activities |
(99.00) |
(56.00) |
(69.00) |
|
Cash Flow from Financial Activities |
2,032.00 |
(1,113.00) |
(1,300.00) |
|
Net Cash Flow |
2,633.00 |
146.00 |
(186.00) |
|
Stock-Based Compensation |
97.00 |
154.00 |
127.00 |
|
Common Stock Dividends Paid |
(42.00) |
(172.00) |
(181.00) |
According to the world tourism barometer, the tourism industry reported a decline of up
to 65%. The revenue for the last three years shows a major decline. For example, Hilton Hotel, a
hotel with global recognition, shows the annual report as follows. $ 4,307 in 2020 down from
$8,908 in 2018 and $9,452 in 2019, respectively. The projections in the next coming year range
from $ 4,378 to $4,518 (Williams et al, 2021).
Most of the countries gave travel restrictions to their citizens to increase the safety of their citizens. In the first few weeks after the cases, the hotel industry received an income from the foreign people traveling due to the various government's restrictions on mandatory quarantines or isolation in facilities provided. Most of the facilities were hotels and institutions. The revenue collected was from accommodation and meals. Some countries introduced
nighttime curfews and limits to essential movement. Several businesses thrive at night in the tourism industry, which means that the nighttime curfew makes the facilities out of business.
The loss of jobs and pay cuts for employees in tourism is a risk to the security and livelihoods of people because there is a desperate need for the basic needs; hence there is an increase in the crime rate because of the effect in the loss of jobs translates to the loss of income in other sectors of the economy. Countries that depend on wildlife in tourism have recorded an increase in poaching of wild animals because of the decrease in tourists and a decrease in employees taking care of the parks and reserves.
The tourism industry stakeholders must understand and forecast their finances in the future and find ways of working around the pandemic in ways that enable the businesses to remain sustainable. One of the expectations is there is a likely change in consumer behavior. The level of physical interaction has significantly reduced because of the need to have social distance and reduce exposure. Most clients try to avoid interaction with other people and visit different places as a precautionary measure and question the sanitization of the places visited. The precautionary measure means that the consumer behavior is likely to change because most consumers opt for preferences that avoid covid in place (Jones et al, 2020).
Other sectors affected.
Several sectors depend on the thriving success of the tourism industry, which means that the effects of covid 19 affect businesses directly and indirectly and eventually affect the country's economy.
Positive impact from Covid 19
Insurance
Despite the adverse effects globally, the insurance industry is one of the industries that have had significant effects because of the pandemic. Insurance companies have adjusted their policies are created new policies that cover the effects of the pandemic and cushioning clients from the losses faced. Since insurance companies have gained the additional business, the tourism sector businesses have had to risk their expenses to cater to the additional premiums for the additional covers (Jones et al, 2020). While the tourism industry's income is negative, the insurance industry, especially health and life insurance, is generating more revenues because of the need to save money from hospital bills. Besides, potential clients are changing their choices and decisions, and money that would be spent on tourism is channeled to other industries such as insurance. Most people in developing countries are becoming more aware of the importance of having health insurance for themselves, and they are dependent. For instance, this means the money saved trips either as a domestic or foreign tourist is taken to paying premiums for health insurance to cater for any disease or complication arising from COVID 19 (Chang et al, 2020).
Pharmaceuticals
Adapting new healthy lifestyles and improving hygiene has seen a rise in the pharmaceutical industry's revenues through the sale of products such as masks, hand sanitizers, and health supplements. There has been an increase in the demand for health supplements to increase the immune system. Most of the clientele are people who seek medical assistance through over-the-counter medication and prefer home care treatment methods. There is a decline of people seeking medical attention in hospitals due to the fear of contracting the disease or being diagnosed with the disease and the treatment process that follows. The availability of such treatment procedures helps the tourism industry because the clients may use various facilities while being cautious hence avoid contracting or transmitting the disease (Jones et al, 2020).
Online platforms
The ICT industry has recorded a rise in the design of new applications and software to help businesses that have changed the working strategy and embraced the remote working strategy for their businesses. As a precautionary measure, most people and organizations have transformed their mode of handling business and work. There is an increase of people working from home to avoid exposure and increasing the risk of contracting the disease. Organizations had to invest in online meeting platforms for video conferencing such as Zoom and Teams to allow people to work from home and work effectively, especially organizations that transacted in different countries. The online platforms have increased their revenues due to the increased number of customers (Jones et al, 2020).
There is also an increase in online business and product delivery by people because of avoiding public spaces. Restaurants and other commodity businesses use this to capitalize on gaining revenue because they meet the customers' needs through online sales and purchases. The tourism industry may use a digital platform as a marketing strategy to create awareness of available destinations and services offered in such areas (Chang et al, 2020).
Negative impact
Agriculture
Many businesses in the tourism sector deal with food, such as hotels, restaurants, and airlines. The success of the tourism industry relies heavily on agriculture because of the food requirements for the clients. Due to the covid 19 effects, most of the agriculture businesses have been negatively affected because of the reduced demand from the tourism business. Most of the produce in Agriculture is perishable commodities; therefore, for farmers to reduce the losses incurred, some resulted in selling their commodities at a lower price than the usual market rates
because there was a higher supply than the market demand. Alternatively, farmers had to increase the commodities' prices to cover the losses of producing the food, which means that the businesses in the tourism industry increase the price of commodities to an already suffering economy due to the reduced number of clients (Chang et al, 2020). The cessation of movements and border controls have also made it difficult for the agricultural produce to reach the destination in good conditions. In most countries, especially the developing countries, most tourist business is in the urban centers while agricultural business is in the rural areas. There is a definite requirement of transportation for the commodities to the destination within the shortest time. To solve the challenge, the farmers require permits to allow them to transport food to other destinations. In most cases, getting the permits takes long and costs them more; hence, most farmers opted not to transport their produce, especially small-scale farmers.
There will be a decline in agricultural production in the long run because the losses mean that farmers might not have the capital in the next season for crop farming or food supply for the animal farmers. Without proper strategies, the food shortage is likely to affect more people than the tourism industry (Chang et al, 2020).
Local financial institutions such as banks have recorded a decline in revenues due to the low customer numbers and low revenues. The institutions are at risk of running losses, especially from bad debts due to unpaid loans invested in the tourism industry.
Initially, when the pandemic started, there was a decrease in the price of fuels. However, with the stabilization of the economy, the fuel prices gradually increased, making it difficult for the transport sector in tourism to make profits. The high fuel costs mean an increase in electricity prices, which is an essential factor in food, beverage, and accommodation.
The real estate sector has seen adverse effects, with people opting for other investment forms that may be easier in liquidity. In the tourism industry, most businesses closed; hence the real estate investment was repossessed due to lack of payment for rent or leases. Businesses with a high amount of fixed assets than current assets have lower liquidity or solvency ratios, making it difficult to access financial leverage because the liquidity ratios determine the business's leverage ratios. There is a decline in real estate investments, including investments in the tourism industries such as hotels' construction.
Long-term expectation for regaining profit
The recovery of the tourism industry highly depends on the collaboration between the government and other stakeholders. The government and shareholders of the business need to team up and come up with strategies to help the people from further losses. Tax relieves one of the ways the government helps the industry recover from the increased expenses and losses during the pandemic period. Tax relieves ensures that the revenue collected helps in rebuilding and investing in the facilities and attract customers. The tax levies can be made to a specific duration.
Similarly, the government may also offer to assist businesses in the industry with financial aid such as grants and loans with minimal interest. They strive to put the businesses back to the market rates. Minimal interest in financial aid also means that the industry does not charge clients high amounts as previously but focuses on increasing the demand.
The recovery process requires changes in the financial policies following the guidelines set in place to recover an economy, such as the national recovery act. The policies based on the multiplier effects that tourist industries have in the country may help in the recovery of the country's general economy. The ratio of the fiscal multiplier in tourism is high because some
industries and sectors depend on the industry, such as infrastructure and agriculture. Innovating new marketing strategies such as advertising tourist destinations and showcasing how conversant facilities are in line with covid 19 is a crucial way to attract customers. The strategy is achievable both physically and virtually (Jones et al, 2020).
Invest in training more people who will work in the businesses in the tourism sectors, especially on the digital platform, to revive the industry. The stakeholders must be conversant with the business's recovery strategies to capitalize on the business opportunities for the clients. Some of the strategies may be creating awareness for the clients and offering information on the benefits of why the clients need to engage in the business (Jones et al, 2020).
The government and financial institutions need to seek financial leverage from international organizations such as WHO or IMF to boost the economy and help revive back the sectors that might take a while to get clients. Financial aid helps to assist the staff members in these industries with an income as they seek other alternatives to earn a living. The financial assistance also helps the businesses to invest in materials and equipment that meets the safety regulation, such as the purchase of sanitizers, masks, and thermometers to be used in the facilities by both employees and clients (Chang et al, 2020).
Conclusion
The pandemic effects may affect the economy for several years, and in some instances, some businesses may never recover to the level they were before the pandemic. The management or business owners need to think of new strategies to keep their financial status on a going concern and have a promising future. The pandemic will see a change in most clients' social behavior; hence, the businesses need to come up with innovative ways that cater to the different forms and client needs.
Sensitization on COVID 19 will help the tourist business to allow clients from various destinations without stigmatization. It is also essential to train the staff members on the importance of their safety and handle the related crisis.
Questions
1. How does Tourism support the economy?
Tourism supports the economy through job creation and purchases of products from various industries such as agriculture, infrastructure energy and insurance.
2. How has the company financially been affected by the pandemic? Where, can we clearly see the differences? When did started?
The business has had to downsize the number of employees because of the reduced number of revenues. The effect is clearly seen from the month of June especially during summer.
3. Estimate the annual growth rate in Hilton Hotel. dividends over the
2018-2020 period using the data given in the case. Calculate arithmetic average.
$8,908 in 2018 and $9,452 in 2019 4,307 in 2020
=8,908+9,452+4,307
= 22,667 22667/3
Arithmetic Average – =7555.67
4. Calculate the expected return for Hilton Hotel in the next x years.
Yr 1 Probability 0.15 Rate 11%
Yr 2 Probability 0.2 Rate 16%
Yr 1 Expected return – 0.15 * 11% = 0.0165%
Yr 2 Expected return – 0.2 * 16% = 0.032%
5. What is the estimated recovery rate?
The estimated recovery rate is a period of two years because the hotel records the highest sale in the summer season.
6. What strategies can the business use?
The strategies the business may use is apply the uses of technology to advertise the business and the products available. Most of the businesses are leaning to technology hence investing in technology is important.
Work Cited
“Hilton Worldwide Holdings Cash Flow Statement 2005-2021: HLT.” Macrotrends, www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/HLT/hilton-worldwide-holdings/cash-flow- statement.
“Hilton Worldwide Holdings Income Statement 2005-2021: HLT.” Macrotrends, www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/HLT/hilton-worldwide-holdings/cash-flow- statement.
Bakar, Nashirah Abu, and Sofian Rosbi. "Effect of Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) to tourism industry." International Journal of Advanced Engineering Research and Science 7.4 (2020): 189-193.
Chang, Chia-Lin, Michael McAleer, and Wing-Keung Wong. "Risk and financial management of COVID-19 in business, economics and finance." (2020): 102.
Jones, Peter, and Daphne Comfort. "The COVID-19 crisis, tourism and sustainable development." Athens Journal of Tourism 7.2 (2020): 75-86.
Williams, Colin Charles. "Impacts of the coronavirus pandemic on Europe's tourism industry: Addressing tourism enterprises and workers in the undeclared economy." International Journal of Tourism Research 23.1 (2021): 79-88.
,
Final Cases
www.euruni.edu
WHAT IS A
CASE?
A CASE ACADEMICALLY DEVELOPED AND RESEARCHED SOLUTION TO A COMPLEX BUSINESS SITUATION
STUDENTS MUST SUBMIT THE FINAL CASES AFTER THE FINAL DISSERTATION SUBMISSION
THE FINAL CASES MUST BE PRESENTED DURING THE DEFENSE SESSION OF THE DISSERTATION
THE FINAL CASE MUST CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING ELEMENTS:
1. Case Introduction
2. Problem opportunities / challenge identification / dilemma
3. Main facts and events of the core study
4. Research and analysis of the situation
5. Formulation of solutions / answers
6. Discussion and selection of solutions / answers
7. Referencing
HOW SHOULD A CASE BE STRUCTURED?
1. CASE INTRODUCTION
• General overview of the situation
• Definition of the business context
• Identification of the main actors
• Key elements that define the challenge
2. PROBLEM IDENTIFICATION
IDENTIFICATION OF THE PROBLEM AS A STATEMENT
DEFINITION OF THE QUANTITATIVE ELEMENTS
THAT REPRESENT IT
DEFINITION OF THE QUALITATIVE ASPECTS THAT
MUST BE CONSIDERED
3. MAIN FACTS AND EVENTS
WHAT ARE THE
SIGNS THAT REVEAL
THE CHALLENGE?
HOW COULD THE
PROBLEM BE
MEASURED?
WHAT ARE THE MAIN
FACTORS THAT
HAVE PRODUCED
THIS SITUATION?
4. RESEARCH AND ANALYSIS OF THE SITUATION
Use of additional
sources of external
information
Tools for the
analysis of the
problem
Identification of
external factors
Identification of
internal factors
5. FORMULATION
OF SOLUTIONS
• Based on:
✓ The business context
✓ Your conclusions from the situational analysis
✓ The available resources
6. DISCUSSION AND SELECTION OF SOLUTIONS
Define the pros and cons of the proposed solutions
Determine the different expected scenarios
Justify your selection, according to benefits / risks
7. REFERENCING
• Used Bibligraphy
• Additional data sources
(Harvard style)
,
1
GUIDELINES FOR FINAL CASES
STYLE GUIDE
Overall document length: 3000 – 5000 words (excluding bibliography)
DOCUMENT STRUCTURE
– Cover page
– Table of Contents
– Main Body: Case Analysis
– Conclusion
– Bibliography
DOCUMENT STYLE
– Font: Arial or Times New Roman
– Text size 12 pt
– Layout Align left (flush-left ragged-right)/Do not use “Justify”
– Line spacing 1.5l
– Hyphenation Off: do not hyphenate
– Page numbers Bottom right
– References Reference Footnotes only. No endnotes. Students should follow the Harvard referencing
style.
– Numbering Consecutive throughout the document, beginning with 1 on the introductory page. Pages
prior to the introduction must appear in roman numerals Font Arial or Times New Roman
– Footnote size 10pt
– Location Bottom left of each page
– Language use/spelling style Students are free to use either U.K. or USA English, but they must be
consistent. A spelling and grammar check can help students. Marks will be deducted when ‘red
and/or green lines’ appear in the digital copy.
DEADLINES
DEFENCE DETAILS
– 8-10 minutes per case
– 5 minutes Q&A
– Context
– Conclusion
– 5- 10 slide – Visual (avoid too much text)
– Defence (online or on campus)
2
FINANCIAL CASE RUBRICS: CRITICAL THINKING
Element Unacceptable (F) Borderline (D) Partially Proficient (C) Proficient (B) Accomplished (A)
Problem Identification
The student failed to correctly identify the issue(s); analysis was incorrect or too superficial to be of use; information was misinterpreted
The student correctly identified the issue(s) but analysis was weak. An absence of context – the work is basically descriptive with little analysis.
The student correctly identified the case (issues), taking into account obvious environmental/contextual drivers. There is evidence of analysis but it lacks depth.
The student correctly identified the issue(s), taking into account a variety of environmental and contextual drivers. Key case information has been identified and analyzed.
The business issue has been correctly identified, with a competent and comprehensive explanation of the financial problem and its considerations. Impact on company operations and financial situation has been correctly identified. Thorough analysis of the issue is presented.
Information
Gathering
Information was taken at face value
with no questioning of its relevance
or value. Gaps in the information
were not identified or were incorrect.
An information gap was identified
and the student found additional
information to fill it. However, this
was limited in scope. Weak criteria
for the selection of necessary
information.
The student correctly identified at
least one information gap and found
relevant information, but which was
limited in scope. Some evidence of
sound criteria for selecting
information but not consistent
throughout. Needs expansion
Relevant information gaps were
identified and additional relevant
information was found to fill them. At
least two different types of sources
were used. The student
demonstrates coherent criteria for
selecting information but needs
greater depth.
Thestudent showed skill in gathering
information and analyzing it for the
purposes of filling the information
gaps identified. Comprehensive and
relevant
Conclusions The student formed a conclusion, but
it was not reasonable. It was either
unjustified, incorrect or unrelated to
the case in hand.
The conclusion was reasonable but
lacked depth and would not be a
basis for suitable financial strategy
development
The student reached conclusions but
they were limited and provided
minimal direction for decision-making
and solutions.
The student evaluated, analyzed and
synthesized to create a conclusion(s)
which support decisions and
solutions.
The student evaluated, analyzed,
synthesized all information provided
to create a perceptive set of
conclusions to support the decisions
and solutions
Solutions The student attempte,
unsuccessfully, to solve problems.
The student used problem solving
techniques to make decisions about
simpler issues but disregarded more
complex issues. Implications of the
decision were not considered.
Alternatives were not offered.
The student used financial techniques
to make appropriate decisions about
simpler issues. The solution has
limited benefit but does show
understanding of implications of the
decision. Alternatives were
mentioned but not explored.
The student used financial techniques
to make appropriate decisions about
complex issues. Relevant questions
were asked and answered. A realistic
solution was chosen. Alternatives
were identified, explored and ruled
out
The student used problem solving
techniques to make thoughful,
justified decisions about difficult and
conflicting issues. A realistic solution
was chosen which would provide
maximum benefit to the company.
Alternative solutions were explored
and ruled out.
3
CASE RUBRICS: CRITICAL THINKING SCORE GUIDE
Element Unacceptable (F) Borderline (D) Partially Proficient (C) Proficient (B) Accomplished (A)
Problem
Identification
The student failed to correctly
identify the issue(s); analysis was
incorrect or too superficial to be
of use; information was
misinterpreted
The student correctly identified the
issue(s) but analysis was weak. An
absence of context – the work is
basically descriptive with little
analysis.
The student correctly identified the
case (issues), taking into account
obvious environmental/contextual
drivers. There is evidence of analysis
but it lacks depth.
The student correctly identified the
issue(s), taking into account a variety
of environmental and contextual
drivers. Key case information has
been identified and analyzed.
The business issue has been correctly
identified, with a competent and
comprehensive explanation of key
driving forces and considerations.
Impact on company operations has
been correctly identified. Thorough
analysis of the issue is presented.
Information
Gathering
Information was taken at face
value with no questioning of its
relevance or value. Gaps in the
information were not identified
or were incorrect.
An information gap was identified
and the student found additional
information to fill it. However, this
was limited in scope. Weak criteria
for the selection of necessary
information.
The student correctly identified at
least one information gap and found
relevant information, but which was
limited in scope. Some evidence of
sound criteria for selecting
information but not consistent
throughout. Needs expansion
Relevant information gaps were
identified and additional relevant
information was found to fill them. At
least two different types of sources
were used. The student
demonstrates coherent criteria for
selecting information but needs
greater depth.
The student showed skill in gathering
information and analyzing it for the
purposes of filling the information
gaps identified. Comprehensive and
relevant
Conclusions The student formed a conclusion,
but it was not reasonable. It was
either unjustified, incorrect or
unrelated to the case in hand.
The conclusion was reasonable but
lacked depth and would not be a
basis for suitable strategy
development
The student reached conclusions but
they were limited and provided
minimal direction for decision-making
and solutions.
The student evaluated, analyzed and
synthesized to create a conclusion(s)
which support decisions and
solutions.
The student evaluated, analyzed,
synthesized all information provided
to create a perceptive set of
conclusions to support the decisions
and solutions
Solutions The student attempte,
unsuccessfully, to solve problems.
The student used problem solving
techniques to make decisions about
simpler issues but disregarded more
complex issues. Implications of the
decision were not considered.
Alternatives were not offered.
The student used problem-solving
techniques to make appropriate
decisions about simpler issues. The
solution has limited benefit but does
show understanding of implications
of the decision. Alternatives were
mentioned but not explored.
The student used problem solving
techniques to make appropriate
decisions about complex issues.
Relevant questions were asked and
answered. A realistic solution was
chosen. Alternatives were identified,
explored and ruled out
The student used problem solving
techniques to make thoughtful,
justified decisions about difficult and
conflicting issues. A realistic solution
was chosen which would provide
maximum benefit to the company.
Alternative solutions were explored
and ruled out.
4
PRESENTATION GRADING
Element Unacceptable (F) Borderline (D) Partially proficient (C) Proficient (B) Accomplished (A)
Visuals Visuals are poorly designed,
containing only words and are
used as notes. More than 5
spelling mistakes. Relevance is not
clear
Visuals are fairly mundane and not
always relevant to the presentation
development. Fewer than 5 spelling
mistakes
Visuals are well designed. Generally,
support the argument, but some are
irrelevant or unclear
Professionally designed but there are
too many (some irrelevant) or are
missing. Support the development of
the presentation
Professionally designed. Attractive,
relevant and add to understanding.
Support the development of the
presentation
Content The content is a simple repetition
of written work with no
amendments to language or style.
The development is confusing and
does not justify conclusions
The content is generally clear but
there are gaps in the development
or information which is not relevant
is given too much importance
The content is clear showing
knowledge of the area. Improvements
would help to justify conclusions
Competent development of content
showing in-depth knowledge of subject
area.
The content is clear, well developed
and interesting. Conclusions are clearly
justified. Appropriate language style
and shows thorough, in-depth
understanding of the subject area
Questions and
answers
The candidate was unprepared
and unable to answer pertinent
questions
The candidate attempted to answer
the questions but not always
appropriately
The candidate was able to answer the
questions, but did not expand on
question areas
The candidate was well prepared to
answer questions and showed in-depth
knowledge of the subject area.
Expanded on answers
The candidate showed in-depth
knowledge, was well-prepared for the
questions and expanded answers in-
depth showing ownership of the subject
area.
